Comparing Roof Options for Homes in Jupiter and Palm Beach County
If you’re planning a new roof or replacing an old roof in Jupiter, Palm Beach Gardens, or anywhere in Palm Beach County, you’ve probably asked yourself: Is a metal roof better than shingles? It’s a common question among homeowners, and for good reason. With Florida’s intense sun, high humidity, and frequent storms, choosing the right roofing materials matters more than ever.
Let’s break down the differences between metal roof vs shingles and so you can make the best decision for your roofing project.
Durability and Lifespan
Metal Roofs: Metal roofs tend to last 40–70 years, depending on the metal roofing materials and the quality of the metal roof installation. In coastal areas like Tequesta and Jupiter Farms, standing seam metal roofs offer excellent resistance to extreme weather conditions such as salt air, moisture, and high winds. The weather resistance and long lifespan make metal roofing systems a strong choice for the Florida climate.
Shingle Roofs: Traditional asphalt shingles typically last 15–30 years. While architectural asphalt shingles and dimensional shingles improve wind resistance and durability, they can still suffer from algae growth, curling, or lifting—especially in hot climates.
Verdict: If you’re looking for a long-term solution with less frequent maintenance, metal roofs offer superior performance and longevity.
Storm and Hurricane Resistance
Metal Roofing: Metal roofing panels can handle wind speeds up to 140+ mph. This makes installing a metal roof a great choice in hurricane-prone areas. Their interlocking systems shed rain and debris efficiently, lowering the chance of roof damage.
Asphalt Shingles: While some architectural shingles are designed for high wind resistance, asphalt roofing is more prone to tearing or blowing off in major storms. This leads to more frequent repairs after tropical systems.
Verdict: For hurricane season protection, metal roofs tend to perform better from damage versus shingle roofs.
Metal vs Shingle Roof Cost Comparison
Metal Roofs: The material cost for a metal roof is higher upfront, often 2–3 times more per square foot than a shingle roof. However, the investment can pay off with lower energy costs, less maintenance, and fewer replacements.
Shingle Roofs: Shingle roof cost is generally lower per square foot, making asphalt shingles ideal for those on a budget. Roof installation is quicker and installation costs are more affordable. But keep in mind that maintenance and replacement may be needed sooner.
Verdict: If you’re focused on long-term value and durability, the metal roof cost can be justified. For short-term affordability, shingles are a solid option.
Appearance and Versatility
Metal Roofs: Today’s metal roofing materials come in a wide range of styles and colors, including metal panels that mimic slate, tile, or even wood shingles. This makes them a great fit for modern homes, coastal builds, or even farmhouse-style properties.
Asphalt Shingles: Traditional asphalt shingles are widely accepted and offer great curb appeal. Many HOAs prefer or require this look. Composite shingles and shingle material types have improved in aesthetics and performance.
Verdict: Both systems provide visual appeal. Choose based on your home’s architectural style and HOA guidelines.
Energy Efficiency
Metal Roofs: Metal reflects solar heat, which can reduce cooling costs significantly in hot climates. Energy efficiency metal roofs may qualify for ENERGY STAR® ratings and contribute to a more energy efficient home. They also pair well with solar panels.
Shingle Roofs: Asphalt shingles tend to absorb more heat, although there are now “cool roof” technologies available with asphalt coating to help manage solar heat.
Verdict: If you want to maximize your home’s energy efficiency, metal roofing makes a better choice.
Environmental Impact
Metal Roofs: Many metal roofing systems are made from recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their lifespan. They are one of the most sustainable roofing industry options available.
Shingle Roofs: Traditional roofing materials like asphalt roofing are generally not recyclable, leading to more waste.
Verdict: For homeowners who want an eco-friendly option, metal wins.
Maintenance and Longevity
Metal Roofs: Metal roofs require less maintenance, though regular roof inspections are still a good idea. Because they’re not susceptible to mold or moss, they typically need fewer repairs over time.
Shingle Roofs: Shingles are easier to repair, but you’ll likely deal with shingle installation issues, wear and tear, and algae growth more frequently.
Verdict: Over the life of your roof system, metal typically requires fewer repairs and offers better long-term protection.
Roof Deck and Pitch Considerations
Both metal and shingle systems need a properly prepared roof deck. In many cases, you can install metal roofing over an existing roof, which may lower overall labor costs. However, roof pitch affects performance: metal performs better on steep slopes where drainage is key.
Final Thoughts: Metal or Asphalt Roof?
So, which is better: a metal or asphalt roof? The answer depends on your needs and budget. If you’re looking for durability, energy efficiency, and low long-term costs, metal wins hands down. But if shingles cost fits your current financial plan and you prefer a traditional look, asphalt shingle roofs are still a dependable option.
Ask a Roofing Contractor You Can Trust
At Luxe Builder Group, we install both metal roofing systems and architectural shingle roofs across Jupiter and Palm Beach County. As a GAF Master Elite® Certified Contractor, we understand the roofing industry inside and out and help homeowners choose the best materials for their property.
Whether you’re considering installing a metal roof, upgrading traditional materials, or replacing an existing roof, our team offers honest guidance based on years of experience. Let us help you protect your investment and increase your home’s value.
Contact Luxe Builder Group today to schedule your free roof consultation.
